08.May.2010 Short Saturday: First Love and Other Sorrows by Harold Brodkey

In Short Saturday I will journal my journey to find 5-star quality short stories. Unlike my book reviews, I will talk more about my thoughts and what I learn, why I choose the story and how I come upon it. Unlike books, I’m willing to take more risk for shorts, because they are.. well.. short, so I won’t waste too much time if I don’t like them. Expect to see a lot of trash and hopefully, some gems. As it is now, I am not a fan of short stories. Dare I say, yet? But hey, like people say, it’s all about the journey, not destination. (which Michelle is joining, yay)

spring flowers

Mom’s flowers last spring

I didn’t think I’d be able to read a short story and write about it this Saturday, but I stole some time reading outside at our backyard, trying desperately to enjoy the last bit of sun before we officially enter winter. Hubby worked on his bike from our round trip of garage sale today, such a happy boy he was. For myself, among other things I got Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck for a buck, such a happy girl I was!

After the first Brodkey’s that I read a few months ago, I’ve decided to give him another go, especially after Sasha‘s raving reviews of his works recently. And what a great short to read under the sun. First Love and Other Sorrows is about young love in the spring, about understanding what it means, and about growing up, growing out of your idealistic love. The narrator is an awkward 16 year old boy living with his beautiful popular sweet sister and their widowed mother. I loved the point of view of a younger brother, talking about his older sister. It reminded me of my younger brothers.

“From my room across the hall I would hear my sister chattering about the men she knew–the ones she dated, the ones she wanted to date, the ones she wouldn’t touch with a ten-foot pole. My mother would interrupt with accounts of her own cleverness, her sorties and successes when young, sometimes laughingly, but sometimes gloomily, because she regretted a lot of things. Then she and my sister would label my sister’s suitors: one or two had family, one had money, one–a poor boy–had a brilliant future, and there were a few docile, sweet ones who were simply fillers, who represented the additional number of dates that raised my sister to the rank of a very popular girl.”

It’s a quiet melancholy story. Short and warm, just like that tiny window of sunshine in the fall.

4 stars

Though I’m still unsure why Jeffrey Eugenides would pick two of Harold Brodkey’s stories for My Mistress’s Sparrow is Dead (the only author given the space), at least he has redeemed himself for me and I will happily read more of his works in the future.

Read Sasha’s review on First Love and Other Sorrows.

Comment Pages

There are 8 Comments to "Short Saturday: First Love and Other Sorrows by Harold Brodkey"

  • Sasha says:

    Thank you for the link. :] “First Love and Other Sorrows” is still my favorite story of Brodkey’s so far. The other book that was in Eugenides’ anthology didn’t quite make me, well, happy. “Innocence,” I think it was called.

    My favorite line in this one would have to be,

    … ‘You and the word ‘beautiful’!” he would say disdainfully, holding his nose and imitating my voice. “Tell me–what does ‘beautiful’ mean?”

    “It’s something you want,” I would say.

    That line (passage?) just stopped me for several moments.

    “Short and warm, just like that tiny window of sunshine in the fall,” beautifully said. Looking forward to sharing more and more short story – reading with you. :]
    .-= [Sasha´s last blog: marginalia || Mouse Guard: Fall 1152, by David Petersen] =-.

    • mee says:

      Sasha, Innocence was the first Brodkey I read which I didn’t like too. Lucky I connected with this one much more. To be honest, the passage above almost just passed me, until you pointed that out–thank you. I look forward to sharing more reads with you too :)

      • Sasha says:

        It’s funny because I passed that line too. Just kept on reading. And then a page after, something was just nagging at me. As if my mind was telling me, “Hey, wait up, you missed something.” And I went back to look at what I could’ve missed, and found this. And I kept reading it to myself. And I felt really whoa.

        That passage, and the experience–that’s what really strikes me about Brodkey. Sometimes, words just pass you by, but authors like him bury some gems that could hit you the right way.

        I feel like I’m not making sense, haha.

        • mee says:

          Haha I understand the experience Sasha! I love it when an author just hits you at all the right places. For me it happened with Truman Capote’s A Christmas Memory. It was the short that gave me faith in short stories and made me want to read more. I used to dislike short stories really. Another one that I just read recently was Chicxulub by T. C. Boyle. My gosh, did it hit me! Awesome experience!

  • Bellezza says:

    My husband likes the garden, and I like my books, just as your husband and you do. Of Mice and Men is such a touching story. I remember seeing the play in London in the late 80′s, and it made me cry. I can hardly read it again because of the sadness, but it’s good when an author can strike such a chord in your heart. It was ‘funny’ to read of you entering Winter as we enter Spring. Still, Winter is my favorite season. ;O
    .-= [Bellezza´s last blog: Pinch-Ups…A Tradition From My Mother With More Than A Pinch] =-.

    • mee says:

      Bellezza, my husband doesn’t exactly like gardening but he’s not really into books too, hah! I like outdoorsy stuff sometimes so I guess I’m bit of both indoor and outdoor girl. But I hate winter :(

      Didn’t know Of Mice and Men was made into play. Wow. Wonder if I will ever get a chance to see that. I love plays!

  • claire says:

    Di, love the picture of the flowers!
    .-= [claire´s last blog: Sodom and Gomorrah] =-.

Trackbacks



Write a Comment

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>