02.Aug.2009 Sunday Salon: Generational Saga Novels

If you dropped by here in the past few weeks and noticed the books I’m reading on my sidebar, you’d see that I have Middlesex by Jeffrey Eugenides and Burnt Shadows by Kamila Shamsie.

MiddlesexBurnt Shadows

They are both saga novels, span across three generations. They both have political and cultural histories wedged in between the main story. They are both multicultural and multinational in characters and geographic locations.

The impact they made on me, however, couldn’t be more different.

I do like one more than the other. One is intimate while the other one distant. I care about the characters in one and I never had interest in the characters of the other one (in fact I’ve abandoned it for a while now since I didn’t really care much about the ill-fate of the hero — whether any of them die or live). I will finish it just because I probably have less than a quarter away, though I don’t really want to.

And now I feel bad because I got that book I don’t like as an advanced copy and the publicist asked me to share my review when I get the chance to write it. There wasn’t pressure or anything. But not only have I taken time way pass the publication date to read it, I also didn’t like it and have to force myself to finish it. It just seems like a bad deal to me now to feel bad just because of a free book. I probably shouldn’t accept request another advanced copy to save myself from the same predicament.

Yes I know you would tell me not to feel bad and just be honest in “professional” way. But I still feel bad, because I feel pressurized to be polite and to at least finish the book. Do you know what I mean?

On the other hand, I’m a bit behind for my challenges. It’s already passed the half year mark and I’m not halfway for a few of them! In particular, I would like to read more for the Lost in Translation challenge. Can you recommend a translated book I cannot miss? (preferably non-Japanese since I’ve read many Japanese translated books)

And back to generational saga novels, can you recommend another good one? I know One Hundred Years of Solitude is one I should try to read. But what else?

The Sunday Salon.com

Comment Pages

There are 7 Comments to "Sunday Salon: Generational Saga Novels"

  • Table Talk says:

    I gave up accepting ARCs because so many of them were turning out to be books that it was hard to say anything good about. “Middlesex’, however, is a different kettle of fish completely. I thought it was a brilliant book. In fact you’ve reminded me to check and see if he has anything else on the way.

  • katrina says:

    I’m having the same problem with challenges, signed up for way too many.
    Isabelle Allende is great for generational fiction, The House of Spirits, Daughter of Fortune to name a few.
    My favourite trabslated book of the year so far is Silk by Alessandro Barrico, it’s translated from Italian.

  • I think the problem is that Middlesex is one of the best books ever written and so reading it along side any other book is only going to show it up.

    I thought Burnt Shadows was OK, but it did have a lot of flaws. and I’m afraid to say that it gets worse as it goes on. I know exactly what you mean about being pressurised to finish it – don’t be – you can still write a great review explaining why you gave it up. Life is too short to waste on bad books and I’m sure that there will be loads of people jumping up to comment about how much they enjoyed reading it.

    I’ve just finished a South American saga called The Invisible Mountain – I’ll have a review up sometime next week, but it was amazing.

  • Michelle says:

    Will be interested to read more of your thoughts on Middlesex – it’s a book I keep hearing good things about but I’m not sure if I’m ready to read it as yet.

  • Gavin says:

    Middlesex is an amazing book and One Hundred Years of Solitude is on my top ten list. How about Midnight’s Children?

  • Suko says:

    I don’t believe this! I started Middlesex on Friday and am almost done reading this fascinating novel, which is generational and multicultural.

  • mee says:

    Table Talk: He definitely is becoming one of my favorite author! I don’t think he has any other book apart from Middlesex and Virgin Suicides (and probably a few short stories?). I guess it takes time to write a good book!

    katrina: You’ve reminded me about Silk. I think I might just read that next. It’s been sort of near the top of my TBR pile for a while and it’s so thin!

    Jackie: Exactly! I’m surprised of how so so well written it is! It’s just nothing like I’ve ever read before. You’re right about reviewing unfinished book. I know you do that and your reviews are still interesting always. I gotta learn to do that too. I still find it really hard not to finish a book that I’ve started/finished more than halfway. It’s a different story if it’s only a chapter or so (then I can just pretend I never pick it up).

    Michelle: It’s actually quite an easy read. It just takes time because it’s so thick and the font is so small.

    Gavin: I hope to read One Hundred Years of Solitude this year. I’m not sure if I’m ready for Midnight’s Children though. It’s a pretty intimidating book.

    Suko: Yay that’s great! I can’t wait to read your review! You definitely read it a lot faster than I am.

Trackbacks



Write a Comment

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>